Rocky Mountain News

HomeBusinessMore Business

Defense: Nacchio was forced to unload stock

Published March 20, 2007 at midnight

Former Qwest CEO Joe Nacchio unloaded nearly $101 million of company stock in early 2001 not because he had insider information that the company was in trouble, but because the board of directors forced him to use his valuable options before they expired, defense attorney Herbert Stern told jurors Tuesday.

Stern also said any warnings Nacchio received from employees about not meeting 2001 numbers referred to internal goals that were higher than the targets Nacchio was giving Wall Street.

Nacchio, who is charged with 42 counts of insider trading, believed "passionately, honestly and fervently" in the company’s publicly stated goals, Stern added during two hours of opening statements at the federal courthouse in Denver on the second day of the trial.

Prosecutors say Nacchio sold the stock because he knew the company’s revenue targets were inflated — information he didn’t share with investors. When the stock later dropped, thousands of shareholders who weren’t privy to the information — including many current and former employees — lost money, some of them their entire retirement savings.

"This is a case about cheating," Assistant U.S. Attorney James Hearty said during his opening statement. "It isn’t a case about accounting. It’s a case about fairness. There would have been nothing wrong with Joe Nacchio selling his shares so long as he told investors about the problems he knew about."

Hearty, who spoke for about an hour and 15 minutes, showed jurors several timelines outlining what Nacchio knew and when, and when he made the stock sales included in the government’s indictment. The number of shares sold during that time — from January to May 2001 — was five times the shares Nacchio sold during the previous 18 months, Hearty said.

Each sale closely followed a warning from other Qwest executives that the company’s revenue targets were too high, largely because the company was depending too much on "one-time" sales of space on its telecommunications network, rather than more stable, recurring business such as home telephone service.

In one memo, then-President Afshin Mohebbi stated the goals were a "huge stretch," Hearty said. In another memo he warned of "big problems" approaching.

Hearty also said Nacchio backdated a form certifying that he had no insider information when he planned a January 2001 stock sale. That form, displayed for jurors, was dated Nov. 3, 2000. But prosecutors said it actually was created Dec. 13 — after Mohebbi issued his first warning to Nacchio.

Seated at the defense table, Nacchio shook his head back and forth at the allegation.

Stern later refuted the accounts of Mohebbi’s memos. In the memo referring to the "huge stretch," Stern said, Mohebbi actually was talking about Qwest’s internal budget, which was called the "stretch budget" because the goals were higher than the publicly stated targets. Nacchio didn’t receive the second memo, which Mohebbi left on his chair, because he was in Appalachia at the time distributing food to poor people, Stern added.

Nacchio sat quietly most of the day, except for when Stern told jurors that the New Jersey man had struggled with his decision to leave the East Coast for the Qwest job in 1997 because he had a son with an emotional illness. That son tried to commit suicide and was hospitalized for about a month in January 2001, Stern later added.

Both times his son was mentioned, Nacchio covered his face with his hand and looked down, then took off his glasses and wiped his eyes with a tissue.

The jury of seven women and 11 men, seated Tuesday morning after a day of jury selection, will continue hearing the case today before U.S. District Judge Edward Nottingham.

Back to Top

Search »