Rocky Mountain News

HomeOpinionEditorials

The CIA's self-critique

Once again, Tenet comes off as asleep at the wheel

Published August 23, 2007 at midnight

Two years ago, the CIA sent to Congress a report of several hundred pages done by its inspector general detailing the agency's errors and missteps leading up to 9/11. The CIA fought strenuously against its release. Based on a heavily edited 19-page summary, it's easy to see why.

Much of the summary spells out what was previously known or guessed at. It found, for example, that there was no "single point of failure" that allowed 9/11 to happen or "silver bullet" that would have prevented it.

Instead, the report recounts an organizational lack of focus and simple presence of mind caused by budget and personnel problems, bureaucratic inertia and, reading behind the lines, what seems a risk-averse institutional culture. And there was a stunning lack of interagency cooperation. Some 50 to 60 CIA officers saw cables relating to two of the future hijackers - that the pair might be trying to enter the United States or were already here - but somehow the State Department and the FBI were never notified.

It wasn't always the CIA's fault. The summary says the National Security Agency refused to let the CIA see raw intercepts of al-Qaida communications. The NSA relented and finally let a single CIA officer review the transcripts, but only for a brief period. What were these people thinking?

The inspector general found that then-CIA Director George Tenet "bears ultimate failure" for devising a strategy to meet what was clearly perceived as a threat at the time and recommended a board of inquiry to hold Tenet and his top deputies accountable. We disagree with that last recommendation, since neither this report nor any other identifies misconduct or illegality on the part of Tenet and his deputies. Punishing them for not instilling a sense of urgency and direction into a sprawling, unfocused bureaucracy - as if they were responsible for 9/11 - strikes us as the sort of scapegoating that will deter, not inspire, future agency risk-taking.

In fact, at a remove next month of six years, the 9/11 post-mortems fall into the category of history. That history, it now seems clear, will not be kind to Tenet, however much George W. Bush sought to influence it by bestowing an undeserved Presidential Medal of Freedom on Tenet three years ago.

Back to Top

Search »